Mansion Sports – A stunning upset marked the beginning of the 2025–26 season as Grimsby Town eliminated Manchester United in the second round of the Carabao Cup. 

The League Two side delivered a remarkable performance against the Red Devils, sealing a historic victory through a dramatic penalty shootout that extended to 26 spot-kicks. 

This defeat marked the first time since 2014 that Manchester United have been eliminated at this stage of the competition.

A 26-Penalty Shootout and Christy Pym’s Crucial Role

Grimsby took a two-goal lead before Manchester United managed to level the score in the dying minutes, forcing the game into a penalty shootout. 

Goalkeeper Christy Pym emerged as one of the heroes of the night by saving Matheus Cunha’s decisive penalty, which could have sealed the win for United. 

After the match, Pym delivered a surprising yet humorous statement, admitting that he is a Manchester United supporter himself, leaving him with mixed emotions over the result.

Outstanding Display Despite Personal Dissatisfaction

Throughout the contest, Pym made seven crucial saves, including several spectacular stops that kept Grimsby’s hopes alive. 

Yet, the goalkeeper confessed he was not entirely satisfied with his performance, believing he could have done better during the shootout. 

Despite his self-criticism, his vital contributions proved decisive in guiding his team to a historic triumph.

A Historic Night for Grimsby Town

This fixture marked the first meeting between Grimsby Town and Manchester United since 1948, and the result now stands as one of the most memorable victories in the club’s history.

Knocking out a Premier League giant not only brought immense pride to their supporters but also underscored Grimsby’s determination to make their mark in the competition.

Upcoming Clash Against Sheffield Wednesday

Following this monumental win, Grimsby Town advance to the third round of the Carabao Cup, where they are set to face Championship side Sheffield Wednesday.

Scheduled to be played between September 15 and 22, the match presents both a new challenge and an opportunity for Grimsby to extend their fairytale run in England’s domestic cup competition.